Holding a High Standard for Music

Fact: Almost all music is shitty.

Over the past year, I have been pas­sively rat­ing my music library on iTunes (or my iPhone) as I lis­ten to them.  I have finally rated my entire library and it feels good, really, really good.

Why should you rate your music?

Maybe you’re the type of guy who down­loads a ter­abyte of music and brags about how much music you have.  But what good is it if it’s mostly SHIT?  Qual­ity over quantity.

  • You can eas­ily sort out your bad music from the good, delete the bad ones and stream­line your library.
  • You can make a playlist of only your best music (5-star!), shuf­fle it and enjoy every­thing you hear!

How to rate music and what mean­ing to give to the stars

In iTunes, you have the option of rat­ing some­thing from 1 to 5 stars.

If you don’t have the Rat­ing col­umn enabled in your main Music library, go to View -> View Options, make sure “Rat­ing” is selected and click OK.

Here’s how I go about it:

1 star: I’m going to delete it.  Why would I ever lis­ten to some­thing that I think is that shitty?

2 stars: Marked for deletion.

3 stars: Nor­mally I would delete this (and I prob­a­bly will), but the ONLY rea­son I’m keep­ing it is because it has sen­ti­men­tal value.

4 stars: It’s really, really good, but it’s not the BEST.

5 stars: The cream of the crop.  The BEST of that genre.  It’s TIMELESS.  Mean­ing you could play this track 5, 10, 20 years from now and you couldn’t tell if it was made yesterday.

How HIGH of a musi­cal stan­dard do you hold?

I looked at my broth­ers iTunes library one day and noticed it was full of either 5-star rated tracks or unrated tracks, with noth­ing in between.  He told me he deletes music that he con­sid­ers 4.9 out of 5 stars or lower.

I was astounded when he told me that and in dis­be­lief imme­di­ately asked him, “You even delete some­thing you think is 4 out of 5?!”

Armand replied with, “Yup.  There is so much music out there that I have no rea­son to keep the songs that are not the absolute best.”

That made a lot of sense, but it was still a dif­fi­cult thing to process and accept, let alone actu­ally put into prac­tice.  I find it hard to get rid of 3-star rated songs, let alone 4, so that’s quite the stan­dard Armand is hold­ing onto.  It makes sense though, espe­cially for a DJ like him­self.  It’s def­i­nitely one of the assets that sets him apart in such an over-saturated field.

While I wish this was true, I’m afraid the truth is that most peo­ple have really low standards.

After thoughts…

It took me over a year to actu­ally rate my music and I find myself NEVER lis­ten­ing to the 3-star rated crap.  If a 3-star rated song goes on, I don’t even let it play for more than 20 sec­onds before chang­ing it.  So I’m ready to delete them, despite their sen­ti­men­tal value.  It took me months to real­ize this and I never would have been aware of this trend if I hadn’t rated my library so thor­oughly. I just don’t know if I have the balls to delete the 4-star tracks.  Not yet anyway.

  • Can YOU get your­self to delete any­thing that’s not the best?
  • Can YOU adhere to Armand’s standards?

Not sure?  Well, start rat­ing your songs and start that cleans­ing process!

Update:  There’s a part 2 to this arti­cle, made exactly 3 months later.  It involves a new devel­op­ment where I essen­tially want to rate some songs as 6-stars, haha.